This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.Find out more here

GET INVOLVED

To discuss how you and your organisation can get more involved with The Work Foundation, please contact us.

Call 020 7976 3575 or email info@theworkfoundation.com

CONTACT

Professor Jackie Leach Scully
Co-director of Policy Ethics and Life Sciences Research Centre
Professor Jackie Leach Scully

'Human enhancement: making better people or making people better?

Authors: Professor Jackie Leach Scully Jackie Leach Scully, Professor of Social Ethics and Bioethics, Newcastle University

11 June 2013

Discussion of enhancements focuses on normal, healthy people who want to improve how they function. Until very recently, the line between enhancement and therapy was clearly marked out in terms of who it applied to. Therapy is about restoring people to the norm (making people better) while enhancement is taking people beyond the norm (making better people). The people in need of therapy are disabled or chronically ill, while those who might want to be enhanced are just…normal people who want to be better than normal. In the debate about the impact of enhancement technologies on the world of work, disabled people don’t really seem to figure.

But things are not that simple, and in many ways disabled people are now key to our thinking about technological self-improvement and its effect on the world of work. Making clear distinctions between therapy and enhancement is becoming increasingly difficult. For one thing, some of the interventions (pharmacological or otherwise) that enhance the abilities of normal people are likely to start life as therapies aimed at people with particular conditions. The cognitive enhancing drugs of the future, for example, may be developed to treat pathological memory loss in people with dementia; but suppose that same drug turned out to improve memory in the unaffected too? Suppose an implant developed for visual impairment could be adapted for normally sighted people to expand the range of what they can see?

This blurring of the boundaries will have implications for access to innovative and sophisticated technologies. Many of these interventions will be expensive. Disabled people on average are less likely to be in employment and more likely to have low incomes than non-disabled people; they are the least able to pay for the technologies that might get them into the workforce. Although the state is legally required to provide some support to disabled people, their claims will become more contested if the restorative technology that a disabled person needs is indistinguishable from an enhancement.

It’s widely noted that, in our competitive society, the availability of performance-enhancing technologies is likely to lead to pressure to use them, particularly in the workplace and in education.  The pressure on disabled people to use them will have damaging knock-on effects for those who can’t, or who simply don’t want to. Why should people not want to use a restorative technology if they could? There are several reasons, but one that is often neglected is that a disability can be a part of someone’s identity. While people who become disabled in later life are likely to want to restore the capacities they had before, many people who have been disabled for all or most of their lives experience that as their normality. They may, quite understandably, be reluctant to adopt technologies that will make them more ‘normal’ by other people’s standards, but which for them would be a shift away from their norm. Yet the combination of social expectations and economic pressures may make it difficult or even impossible to choose not to.

And in this situation, what’s at stake is the readiness of society to welcome a diversity of ways of being, and of working. The current legal obligation of employers and other areas of public life to accommodate disability is based on the idea that society as a whole bears some responsibility to be flexible around the capacities of its citizens. Restorative technologies shift the responsibility of adaptation back onto the disabled person, thereby rolling back the important achievements of the past decades in which disabled people have begun to be accepted, as they are, as full members of society. Ultimately, the same applies to everyone, nondisabled and disabled alike, exposed to the expectation that they will change themselves to keep up with ever-increasing pressures in work and in education.

None of this means that performance-enhancing technologies should be rejected, of course. But disabled people and others are right to be concerned not just about a potential loss of jobs, but about the effect of augmenting technologies on society’s expectations of normality and tolerance of difference.

The Work Foundation 2013 Annual Debate 'Will robots and enhanced humans steal our jobs?' will be held on 11 June. Join the debate on Twitter #stealingourjobs

Comments in Chronological Order (Total 28 Comments)

com444

15 May 2014 11:58AM

DGGP Pvt. Ltd. is a leading manufacturer of Guar Fast Hydration Polymers used in Gas Oil Fields fracturing Industry in the world.
Natural polymer suppliers
FH powder suppliers

Roger

22 May 2014 12:16PM

The title itself was good because it made me to think for a couple of minutes as which of the options were right. I think, human enhancement will make the people better because it will make them to think and act for a better tomorrow.
robert edens law office

Tony

21 Jul 2014 12:38PM

Very well written article describing the distinctions between therapy and enhancement. Thanks for the article.
Regards,
amazon

abc

26 Jul 2014 7:26PM

The primary a few months of my site there were no remarks; simply provide for it time; now they come in like insane consistently! Much obliged. toronto patent lawyers

Donald

31 Jul 2014 1:48PM

Amazing blog and information thanks for sharing. http://congresonacional.tv/pfizer-innovating-their-pharmaceutical-manufacturing-process/

jackle

01 Aug 2014 12:03PM

You have a real ability for writing unique content. I like how you think and the way you represent your views in this article. I agree with your way of thinking. Thank you for sharing. - See more at:
lounge furniture rentals tucson

abc

09 Aug 2014 2:04PM

Easily, the article is actually the best topic on this registry related issue. I fit in with your conclusions and will eagerly look forward to your next updates. Just saying thanks will not just be sufficient, for the fantasti c lucidity in your writing. I will instantly grab your rss feed to stay informed of any updates.
24 hour locksmith sandy springs ga

arjune

08 Sep 2014 10:30AM

That is really amazing dear buddy keep it up and say all is well.
how to be rich

jackle

08 Sep 2014 11:02PM

So luck to come across your excellent blog. Your blog brings me a great deal of fun.. Good luck with the site.
http://www.cars-for-sales.com/category/acura-information/

jackle

11 Sep 2014 3:00AM

First and foremost You got an extraordinary web journal .I will be intrigued by more comparative points. i see you got truly extremely valuable themes , i will be continually checking your web journal much obliged.
Vec o tem tukaj

jackle

12 Sep 2014 5:47AM

Took personal time to peruse all the remarks, yet I truly reveled in the article. It turned out to be Very useful to me and I am certain to all the commentators here! It's generally decent when you can be educated, as well as entertained!
https://rebelmouse.com/teethwhitening4youreviews/

Amelia1a

15 Sep 2014 7:54AM

Fantastic blog post. The post affects a lot of urgent challenges of our society. We can not be uninvolved to these challenges. This post gives good ideas and concepts. Very informative and practical. the truth about cellulite video

Mittal

15 Sep 2014 10:36AM

The world is changing fast. people are also being changed.day by day we are becoming more dependant on degital system. ?????? ?????? ?????????

Charles Peter

29 Sep 2014 10:47AM

This is really outstanding blog posting and i am very glad to read this informational topic. Thank you very much for uploading great article about human enhancement.
rapidassignments.co.uk

jack

11 Oct 2014 1:23PM

I might want to thank you for the exertions you have made in composing this article. I am trusting the same best work from you later on also.
group therapy

jack

12 Oct 2014 3:33PM

Thanks for creating the page! Im positive that it will be very popular. It has good and valuable content which is very rare these days.
compressor guide

metal coffee table

13 Oct 2014 10:04AM

It's tricky to sort the great from the terrible frequently, however I think you've nailed it!metal coffee table

online dentist

06 Dec 2014 7:24AM

I think you've nailed it

PDF Links.three

06 Dec 2014 11:22AM

enhancement technologies on the world of work, disabled people don’t really seem to figure.

you've kept program it you, the hospital's details system usually takes weeks and also months to receive it back.

Adam

19 Dec 2014 8:46AM

It is a great website.. The Design looks very good.. Keep working like that!
Underworld Tattoo

home renovation

20 Dec 2014 7:36AM

accept the changes please? A lot of us accept customized templates, do something for that purpose.

answering service san antonio

21 Dec 2014 7:20AM

A lot of us accept customized templates, do something for that purpose. The Design looks very good

dress gloves for women

21 Dec 2014 9:49AM

lowering your blood sugar, controlling pre, type 1, and type 2 diabetes, and completely eliminating the disease for good in as little as 3 weeks. To sum it up in 4 words, Diabetes Miracle is a “home remedy diabetes cure”.

Suppose an implant developed for visual impairment could be adapted for normally sighted people to expand the range of what they can see? https://www.rebelmouse.com/manifestationmiraclereviews/

resource

23 Dec 2014 6:39AM

I just couldn’t depart your site prior to suggesting that I extremely enjoyed the standard information an individual provide for your visitors? Is gonna be back frequently in order to inspect new posts...

home plans

23 Dec 2014 6:45AM

Hi there everyone, it's my first go to see at this web page, and article is genuinely fruitful.

led pendant lights

07 Jan 2015 6:25AM

from more complex approaches that aren't simple to install to others that are so simple that they can't reveal data in real time.