This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.Find out more here

GET INVOLVED

To discuss how you and your organisation can get more involved with The Work Foundation, please contact us.

Call 020 7976 3575 or email info@theworkfoundation.com

CONTACT

Ian Brinkley
Economic Advisor
Email
Ian Brinkley

Zero hours contracts – nasty, brutish and unfair?

Authors: Ian Brinkley Ian Brinkley

13 June 2013

Yesterday's (12 June) labour market statistics show employment holding up, consistent with some signs of economic recovery. But beneath the surface of the aggregate employment numbers there is also a lot of interest in what sort of jobs we are creating.

Zero hours contracts have become the most high profile example of what some see as ushering in a new era of even greater job insecurity for some. Ed Miliband in his recent speech on welfare reform said, “For too many people in Britain the workplace is nasty, brutish and unfair” and then listed a number of factors, with top of the list “The exploitation of zero hours contracts to keep people insecure.”

Others see it as a logical extension of the UK’s labour market great strengths, the flexibility and diversity of employment. It is this flexibility, some argue, that has allowed the UK to create so many jobs despite the weakest economic recovery on record.

Fear in the workplace of losing a job or being exploited are indeed at unusually high levels, as my recent blog on the findings from the 2012 Skills and Employment Survey showed. Zero hours contracts are very likely to be one driver of that anxiety. But the share of employees who report being fearful of being treated unfairly is so much bigger – around one in four - than the share on zero hours contracts (less than 1%), that it can only be one of many factors. Nor is it safe to assume that everyone on a zero hours contract is fearful.

My guess at the moment is that when considered against some of the bigger changes in the labour market, zero hours may be more significant in replacing existing forms of flexibility rather than leading a dramatic shift towards insecure working. But we always have to be careful about assuming associations between zero hours contracts and wider measures of flexible working. For example, people on zero hours contracts may not report their job as temporary. Moreover, there are significant caveats with the Labour Force Survey statistics identified in my earlier blog . 

However, we can say there is no obvious strong link between zero hours and an upsurge in temporary work. The share of employees who said they were in temporary employment has barely changed since 2010 and is still well below its previous peak in 1997. Nor is there much evidence that people are taking zero hours in order to supplement their main job – the share of people in second jobs has been falling.

If my hunch is right that zero hours are mainly substituting for other flexible employment forms, it is proving hard to pin down the exact nature of that change. The obvious candidate would be agency workers, as employers switched from agency to zero hours contracts to avoid the impact of the Agency Workers Directive. However, there is no statistical evidence that this has so far happened. Both have increased since 2010 and in 2013 levels of employment of agency workers were the highest since the statistics were first collected.

Though somewhat challenging, we think it is important to find out what is really going on around zero hours contracts and the reasons behind the trends. That’s why we are holding an event on 4th July see if we can start to come up with some better answers – and ask what if anything should we do about zero hours. Alongside myself on the panel will be Alison McGovern, MP for Wirral South; Kevin Green, chief executive of the Recruitment and Employment Confederation; Nicola Smith, head of economic and social affairs at the TUC and our chair will be Siobhan Kennedy, the business correspondent at Channel 4 News.

An outright ban would be a radical step and departure from previous practice by successive governments which has preferred to look to legislation and regulation to curb the worst excesses. If we wanted to go down the legal or regulatory route, we would need to identify which aspects of the contract it was desirable and realistic to change.

And as with all forms of employment contracts, practice and workplace relationships matter as much as legal status. Some people in permanent jobs can feel just as insecure and vulnerable to exploitation as those on zero hours contracts. And some people on zero hours may be content with the arrangement if it suits their own needs and there is a trust based relationship with the employer. Can we identify “best practices” and encourage all employers who use zero hours contracts to adopt them?

Comments in Chronological Order (Total 16 Comments)

Will Shepherd

13 Jun 2013 1:18PM

We need more data on the nature of the employment relationship, rather than the just the type of contract. Many on zero hours contracts feel secure and appreciated by their employers, and aren't crying out for change. Ian makes a good point that there are plenty on more substantial employment contracts who feel insecure and exploited, though this is harder to legislate against, and it is easier to pick on something that is black and white like a contract.

Nye Cominetti

26 Jun 2013 5:47PM

Good point. We've been looking into this a bit more recently, and it seems there's a significant evidence gap at the moment. Zero Hours Contracts are likely to be experienced very differently by people in different occupations and at different professional levels. We need to find out which people are in exploitative situations and which enjoy the freedoms that these contracts allow. Looking forward to hearing all these issues discussed at the event.

Susan Santilhano

01 Jul 2013 9:41AM

I worked for Angard (Royal Mail's flexible staff resourcing agency - run by Reed recruitment agency)
The most unfair element of the zero hours contract to me, was that they gave no notice that my work was ending. I arrived at 7.45 on 7 June 2013 for my regular shift 8-4 which had been ongoing since 14 January 2013 and was told not to sign in because told my name was no longer on the list.
Suddenly no work after 5 months full time.
When I asked about the Royal Mail's much touted (see their website) "commitment to dignity and respect in the workplace " Their HR representative said I would need to speak to Angard.

I argue that if the Employer themselves has outsourced recruitment for flexible staffing needs to an external agency, then the Employer should remain answerable for poor conditions of service..ie to give at least 48 hours notice of termination of a regular ongoing working pattern.

I won't even mention the vile practice, of paying three months at £6.19 before a pay increase to £9.73. And consequent reduction back down
to £6.19 if the agency cannot provide work for 6 weeks.




chrissy

30 Jan 2014 12:44AM

Zero contracts are unfair as we can't afford to lose money, i am one of them i am so behind on my bills and barely got money for food let alone going out, i am in tears because i can't afford anything, also i think zero contract is sexist as they said were start looking at this problem when MEN are finding this hard, Us women have got about three jobs because of these zero hours so not fair.

chrissy

30 Jan 2014 12:51AM

About women's hair cut and colour why is it fair that us women got to pay more for our hair it's crazy and again sexist, why can't the price's be dropped so we all pay the same they did it for car insurance made sure were paying the same as men which is fair enough so why can't us women get heard on this and something done?

Oil Field Derivatives suppliers

15 May 2014 11:56AM

Article is very interesting,thanks for your sharing.I will visit this site.welcome to my site:

com444

15 May 2014 11:57AM

DGGP Pvt. Ltd. is a leading manufacturer of Guar Fast Hydration Polymers used in Gas Oil Fields fracturing Industry in the world.

Shell Energy

Website

06 Dec 2014 7:20AM

employment numbers there is also a lot of interest in what sort of jobs we are creating.

PDF Links.seven

06 Dec 2014 11:22AM

numbers there is also a lot of interest in what sort of jobs we are creating.

equipment for sale

18 Dec 2014 9:54AM

numbers there is also a lot of interest in what sort of jobs we are creating.

grants for home repairs

20 Dec 2014 7:35AM

accept the changes please? A lot of us accept customized templates, do something for that purpose.

Cheers for sharing with us your blog. I came across such informative post.Keep up the good work friend.

winter touch gloves

21 Dec 2014 9:52AM

lowering your blood sugar, controlling pre, type 1, and type 2 diabetes, and completely eliminating the disease for good in as little as 3 weeks. To sum it up in 4 words, Diabetes Miracle is a “home remedy diabetes cure”.

website design new jersey

23 Dec 2014 6:44AM

Hi there everyone, it's my first go to see at this web page, and article is genuinely fruitful.

home

23 Dec 2014 7:21AM

I am always searching online for articles that can help me. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also. Keep working, great job!

led light strips 12v

07 Jan 2015 6:25AM

from more complex approaches that aren't simple to install to others that are so simple that they can't reveal data in real time.