This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site you are agreeing to our use of cookies.Find out more here

GET INVOLVED

To discuss how you and your organisation can get more involved with The Work Foundation, please contact us.

Call 020 7976 3575 or email info@theworkfoundation.com

CONTACT

Ian Brinkley
Economic Advisor
Email
Ian Brinkley

How many on zero hours contracts? Nobody knows

Authors: Ian Brinkley Ian Brinkley, director of The Work Foundation

09 July 2013

We held a well-attended and lively event on zero hours contracts at The Work Foundation recently with an excellent panel spanning a wide range of views. Yet a remarkable consensus emerged that we badly needed to find out much more about the use of zero hours contracts in practice before policymakers and organisations could take an informed view of whether more regulation was required and what form it should take.

Like everyone else, we have drawn mainly on the Labour Force Survey (LFS) for our information on zero hours contracts and as the most recent figures show in our recent infographic , around 200,000 across the economy in the fourth quarter of 2012. Yet a recent answer to a Parliamentary Question (PQ) found that using a different and less well-known dataset covering social care there were over 300,000 of these contracts. The actual difference is even higher, because the domestic care estimate is for England only, and the LFS estimate is for the UK.

The same dataset was used for a very good analysis produced for the Low Pay Commission earlier this year. Although focused on the operation of the National Minimum Wage, it also covered the use of zero hours contracts in domestic care. It shows that one driver has been the shift in the way care is now delivered, with the move from contracted blocks of hours to individualised packages within framework agreements. Some private sector providers suggest that zero hour contracts are the only practicable way of delivering care.

As we post this blog, a 90-minute Westminster Hall debate is about to start on zero hours contracts and some MPs have put in freedom of information requests to try and get a better picture of the use of zero hours across the public sector, focusing on universities and the NHS. Once this information is collected and collated, we can add these figures to the domestic care estimates to get a better idea of the true level of zero hours contracts. But we still have no reliable way of telling whether the LFS estimates for private sector services such as hospitality and retail also seriously under-represent the use of zero hour contracts.

If this was not bad enough, there is also a significant problem of seasonality with the interpretation of the statistics produced by the LFS. The question on zero hours is asked in just two quarters, Q2 and Q4. The answers to some questions do not appear to vary very much from quarter to quarter, but others show pronounced differences. For example, in 2012 Q4 the share of people in the top three occupational groups (“knowledge workers”) on zero hours contracts was much higher than in 2012 Q2. So which quarter you pick could have quite an influence on what the data tells you about both the level and the composition of zero hours contracts. As things stand, we have no easy way of knowing which quarter is to be preferred in order to convey a more accurate underlying picture.

The BIS informal consultation announced by the Secretary of State on the use of zero hours contracts was very welcome. But it is increasingly clear that there is much more work that needs to be done to get an accurate picture on the numbers, use and drivers of zero hours contracts on which to base sensible policies and it is not clear that the review in its current form will do the job.

We would favour a more formalised and systematic approach – perhaps along the lines of the Coalition’s Fair Pay Review or through a Select Committee Inquiry – which brings together the information and insights from a wide range of institutions and organisations. This could have three clear goals. Firstly, to get the best possible picture of the incidence and drivers of zero hours contracts from all currently available information sources. Secondly, to set out what good practice looks like. Thirdly, on the basis of the evidence, make recommendations on any legal or regulatory changes or changes in public procurement practice that may be required to discourage abuse and encourage best practice. The Work Foundation would of course be happy to offer support to either of these approaches.

In the meantime, you can tell us if you think zero hours contracts offer flexibility or insecurity by voting in our poll

 

Comments in Chronological Order (Total 14 Comments)

rodene

11 Jun 2014 12:01PM

Guar protein offer a wide selection of products for your specific requirements. Established in the year 2008, we are one of the leading Manufacturer, Exporter and Supplier of Compound Guar Protein Meal Feeds and Poultry Feeds.
Guar meal churi manufacturer
Food grade korma supplier

sinichi245

25 Jul 2014 1:32AM

How many on zero hours contracts? Nobody knows

the topic attract me so i read it it really a good article. hope it can persuade to other people.

poloaer

25 Jul 2014 1:33AM

well it went good.how to get soundcloud comments

Robert Elliot

27 Aug 2014 9:12PM

These zero hour contracts are an issue, a solution for the unemployment issue, but not a real solution, since there's no real security, there's no insurance that you will make a certain amount per month.

Amazon

05 Sep 2014 1:16PM

Great publish so much valuable content that you write here.

Looney

24 Sep 2014 12:00PM

The event was lively as whole and I could attend the conference so that I came to know the zero hour
http://www.qspray.com/
contracts at the Work foundation. Like every other event, the highlight was the labor work force and how it is done on zero hour contracts.

travelsouthwest.org

23 Oct 2014 12:50PM

Air travel become usual globally and has become the luxurious different types of transportationwhich several individuals prefers to pick out. We find find there are plenty of incidents developed like surroundings crashes and all but still a demand for such type of travelling under no circumstances changed. Especially in America the demand from customers for surroundings travelling is above level. Here in air travel the safety precautions are high as compared to road and also ea transport its no wonder that the incidents that occurs with surroundings travels will be veryless when compared to the road and also ea criminal. travelsouthwest.org

fluetlaw.net

23 Oct 2014 12:51PM

Legal requirements is element of our each day lives if is very own or business enterprise therefore you must understand a role as well as function than me. Law is definitely everywhere on the job, when we're also driving, school and each alternate things most people do every day. Without being aware of it, everything most people do calls for law plus every final decision we make in for some reason or a further law is definitely involved. In the following paper I'll be discussing just what exactly law signifies and the kind of laws plus role play at my present jolt. fluetlaw.net

bdlawyer.net

23 Oct 2014 12:51PM

When talking about society legal requirements control society and even helps secure human's perfect and believes that. In lots of cases laws helps solve problem and belief. When you can find law people today must in all probability obey because of it and helps citizen be a little more in regulate. Law enable place the ideal justices ended up being and whether it is needed inside of a community. bdlawyer.net

healthfreedomlaw.net

23 Oct 2014 1:00PM

Foreign law has brought centuries so that you can evolve nonetheless could without difficulty fall sorry victim to electricity if reason would not evolve it has the journey together with the changed scenarios. It is critical for internationalists to comprehend the implications of "change" announced by surfacing subjects with international legal requirements. Responses that are fitted with familiarity by using reality would probably avoid misconstruing a purposes with international legal requirements. healthfreedomlaw.net

noworriesluxuryauto.net

23 Oct 2014 1:00PM

Being aware of the many kinds of insurance just might help you find the insurance exposure you require at a cost you have enough money for thereby allowing you to legally drive while in the state you actually currently are in. Although making use of the outlay and also price for your personal next insurance document are sometimes a good get started whist comparing insurance exposure providers it will be shouldn't a common factor familiar with determine recognise the business to obtain your auto insurance from whenever you actually decide to have a purchase. noworriesluxuryauto.net

autorentool.net

23 Oct 2014 1:01PM

Simply what amount can this sort of software program that is auto huge selection maker ask for? The more complicated accurate question for yourself is simply what amount do most people desire the asking price of many remaining? Nicely, when consumer, you want to test the application also it is good to try outside auto huge selection maker If perhaps it actually brings capital, you have got to can easily make money using it and after that we're prepared to spend excellent price for this too. autorentool.net

PDF Links.seventeen

06 Dec 2014 11:23AM

easily make money using it and after that we're prepared to spend excellent price for this too.

How to fix bad sectors

05 Jan 2015 7:24PM

Their not exactly a solution to the current job industry issue, though I'm seeing quite a lot of them around.